 |
| NO CREDIT TODAY, COME TOMORROW |
Cash and Carry: Can Selling on Credits Kill Your Business?
Running a business is never just about opening shop, stocking products, and waiting for customers to walk in. It is about managing finances, maintaining healthy cash flow, and ensuring that profit remains higher than expenses. One of the most debated issues in small and medium-sized businesses is whether to operate on a cash-and-carry model (payment made instantly at the point of purchase) or to allow sales on credit (customers take products now and pay later).
For decades, many businesses—especially in retail, wholesale, and distribution—have relied on selling on credit as a way to attract customers, build loyalty, and compete in the market. Yet, as attractive as it may seem, credit sales often come with risks that can cripple or even kill a business.
This article takes a deep dive into cash and carry vs. credit sales, analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of both, and answering the big question: Can selling on credits kill your business?
Understanding What Cash and Carry Is All About
The cash and carry model is simple: a customer pays immediately in cash (or via electronic means) for a product or service before taking ownership. There are no delays, no future promises, and no credit risks.
This model is common among retailers in local markets, supermarkets, and wholesalers who sell to small retailers. For example, in a cash-and-carry wholesale shop, a mini-mart owner comes in, pays for the goods in full, and leaves with them.
Core benefits of cash and carry include:
-
Immediate liquidity: The business gets money instantly to restock or reinvest.
-
No bad debts: Since payments are upfront, there is no risk of customers defaulting.
-
Simplified accounting: No need to chase after debtors or manage complex credit records.
-
Faster turnover: Cash flow keeps moving, allowing the business to scale quickly.
Understanding What Selling on Credit Is All About
Credit sales happen when a business allows customers to purchase goods or services with an agreement to pay later. This can be in the form of:
-
Open credit: Goods are supplied, and customers promise to pay later.
-
Hire purchase or installment payments: Customers make gradual payments over time.
-
Corporate credit accounts: Companies order large quantities and settle at the end of the month or quarter.
This model is common in B2B (business-to-business) arrangements. For example, a cement distributor may allow construction companies to take supplies and pay after the project owner releases funds.
Why do businesses sell on credit?
-
To attract more customers who may not have immediate cash.
-
To gain a competitive advantage over businesses that operate strictly cash and carry.
-
To build long-term relationships with clients.
-
To encourage bulk buying.
What Is The Temptation of Credit Sales?
For many entrepreneurs, refusing credit seems like a way to scare customers away. In markets where competition is stiff, offering credit can feel like the only way to keep customers loyal. Imagine a hardware store: if one supplier insists on cash and carry while another offers credit, customers may naturally drift to the second.
However, what looks like a strategy to attract customers can become a trap. Credit sales can reduce liquidity, strain operations, and in the worst cases, push a business into bankruptcy.
Can Selling on Credit Kill Your Business?
The short answer: Yes, it can.
Here’s why:
1. Cash Flow Problems
Cash is the lifeblood of any business. Even if sales are booming, if payments are delayed, the business may lack the funds to restock inventory, pay staff, or cover rent. Many businesses collapse not because they were unprofitable, but because of cash flow gaps caused by unpaid debts.
2. Risk of Bad Debts
Not every customer who promises to pay will keep their word. Some may delay indefinitely; others may vanish. When debts pile up, they eat directly into profit margins. A single large unpaid debt can wipe out the gains of several smaller transactions.
3. Increased Operational Stress
Chasing debtors can be exhausting. Instead of focusing on growth, entrepreneurs spend energy sending reminders, making calls, or even pursuing legal action. This stress distracts from innovation and customer service.
4. Inflated False Success
Credit sales may give the illusion that the business is thriving. Shelves may be empty, orders may be rolling in, but the bank account may still be dry. This “phantom success” can blind entrepreneurs until it’s too late.
5. Supply Chain Disruption
Without immediate cash, businesses may struggle to pay suppliers. This can lead to broken relationships, inability to restock on time, and even loss of supplier trust.
6. Vulnerability During Economic Downturns
During recessions or inflation spikes, customers who owe money may struggle to pay back. Businesses left holding unpaid debts may collapse faster than those operating on cash and carry.
When Credit Sales Make Sense
Does this mean selling on credit should be avoided at all costs? Not necessarily. When properly managed, credit sales can expand business opportunities.
Here are scenarios where credit might make sense:
-
For corporate clients with a strong track record: Large companies that pay monthly or quarterly can provide consistent income.
-
For trusted long-term customers: Businesses may offer limited credit to loyal customers who have proven reliable.
-
To encourage large purchases: Credit can enable bulk buying, especially in B2B industries.
-
As a strategic tool: Offering limited credit terms may help a business penetrate new markets or build brand loyalty.
The key is control. Uncontrolled credit is a recipe for disaster, but strategic, well-monitored credit can enhance growth.
Cash and Carry: Why It Still Wins
Despite the temptation of credit sales, many successful businesses swear by cash and carry. Here’s why:
-
Predictable Growth: With cash upfront, businesses can plan accurately and scale steadily.
-
Debt-Free Model: Avoiding debt keeps both the business and its customers financially disciplined.
-
Stronger Bargaining Power: Cash-rich businesses can negotiate better deals with suppliers.
-
Resilience in Uncertainty: When economies face instability, cash-and-carry businesses survive longer.
How to Protect Your Business If You Must Offer Credit
If your business cannot completely avoid credit sales, here are strategies to reduce risks:
-
Credit Checks: Only extend credit to customers with a proven history of repayment.
-
Set Clear Terms: Define repayment timelines, interest charges, and penalties for late payment.
-
Limit Exposure: Cap the amount of credit given to any single customer.
-
Use Contracts: Document every credit agreement in writing.
-
Incentivize Early Payment: Offer discounts for customers who settle their debts ahead of time.
-
Use Technology: Adopt invoicing and accounting tools to track outstanding payments.
-
Diversify Customers: Avoid over-reliance on one or two large credit clients.
-
Have a Debt Recovery Plan: Partner with professional collection agencies if necessary.
Real-Life Examples
-
The Shopkeeper Who Lost It All:
A small shop owner in Lagos offered credit to almost every customer, believing it would build loyalty. Over time, debts accumulated. Many customers relocated without paying. The business collapsed, not because of lack of demand, but because of unpaid debts. -
The Distributor Who Scaled Wisely:
A beverage distributor initially offered unlimited credit to attract retailers. After struggling with delayed payments, he shifted to partial credit—customers paid 70% upfront and 30% later. This balanced model gave him both liquidity and customer loyalty, allowing the business to grow sustainably.
Finally
The decision between cash and carry vs. selling on credit is not one-size-fits-all. While credit can be a growth tool, it also carries significant risks. For most small and medium-sized businesses, cash and carry remains the safer, more sustainable path.
So, can selling on credit kill your business? Absolutely—if unmanaged. But with discipline, clear terms, and limited exposure, it can be harnessed as a strategic tool.
At the end of the day, the survival of any business depends not just on sales figures, but on cash in hand. As the saying goes: “Profit is opinion, cash is fact.”
Thanks for reading my blog;
Let me know if you have experience the negative impact of selling on credit before, so that I can help you know how to come about it in the subsequent sales, and secure you business.
